Brother Innov-is F580 vs PFAFF creative 4.5
Technical comparison · Sewing and embroidery combos
Both have an automatic needle threader and automatic thread cutting; embroidery sets them apart. The Innov-is F580 embroiders up to 180 × 130 mm, the creative 4.5 up to 360 × 200 mm with the Deluxe hoop of the large unit.
| Parameter | ||
|---|---|---|
| Awards | — | |
| Identity | ||
| Use tier | F2 — Intermediate | F3 — Advanced |
| Price | ||
| Price | ~1000–2200 € | ~5000–11000 € |
| Universal specs | ||
| Weight | 9.3 kg | 11.5 kg |
| Voltage | 220 V | — |
| Category specs | ||
| Embroidery area, long side | 180 mm | 360 mm |
| Embroidery area, short side | 130 mm | 200 mm |
| Embroidery unit | — | Optional |
| Maximum embroidery speed | 650 spm | — |
| Built-in embroidery designs | 193 | 270 |
| Built-in embroidery fonts | 13 | 3 |
| Machine weight | — | 11.5 kg |
| Supported file formats | — | DST (Tajima), JEF (Janome), PES (Brother), EXP (Melco), VP3 (Husqvarna Viking / Pfaff) |
| Connectivity | USB, Wi-Fi, App | USB |
| Included hoops | 2 | creative 120 Square Hoop (120x120 mm), creative Master Hoop (240x150 mm), creative Deluxe Hoop (360x200 mm) per l'unità grande; creative 120 Square Hoop (120x120 mm) e creative Elite Hoop (260x200 mm) per l'unità piccola |
| LED lights | 2 | — |
| Maximum speed | 850 spm | 1050 spm |
| Built-in stitches | 241 | 480 |
| Buttonhole type | One-step | — |
| Buttonhole styles | 10 | — |
| Stitch types | Straight stitch, Triple stretch straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Three-step zigzag, Blind hem stitch, Stretch blind hem stitch, Triple stretch zigzag | Straight stitch, Triple stretch straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Three-step zigzag, Triple stretch zigzag, Blind hem stitch, Stretch blind hem stitch, Elastic overlock stitch |
| Maximum stitch width | 7 mm | 9 mm |
| Maximum stitch length | 5 mm | 6 mm |
| Needle positions | 15 | — |
| Space to the right of the needle | — | 250 mm |
| Dual feed / walking foot system | Integrated in the machine | Integrated in the machine |
| Needle threader | Automatic | Automatic |
| Automatic thread cutter | Yes | Yes |
| Knee lifter | Yes | Yes |
| Automatic presser foot lifter | — | Yes |
| Free arm | Yes | — |
| Thread tension | Automatic | Automatic |
| Display | Colour touchscreen | Colour touchscreen |
| Display size | 3.7 in | 5.7 in |
| Start/stop button | — | Yes |
| Thread sensors | — | Bobbin |
SewingSpecs Awards
Most capable Intermediate
Highest technical score among the 6 sheets in the Sewing and embroidery combos category (intermediate tier): 89/100.
How we assign awards →No awards in this tier.
The differences that matter
- Embroidery area, 180 × 130 mm vs 360 × 200 mm → larger designs fit in a single hoop on the creative 4.5 (Deluxe hoop).
- Built-in stitches, 241 vs 480, and stitch width, 7 mm vs 9 mm → more choice and wider stitches on the creative 4.5.
- Embroidery fonts, 13 vs 3 → more choice for lettering on the Innov-is F580.
- Connections, USB, Wi-Fi and app vs USB only → the F580 has more ways to get designs onto the machine.
Values as declared by the manufacturer.
Which one to choose
Choose Brother Innov-is F580 if…
you embroider motifs up to 180 × 130 mm, often with lettering: 13 fonts against 3. It also connects over Wi-Fi and an app besides USB, and weighs 9.3 kg against 11.5 kg. The trade-off: a smaller embroidery field, 241 built-in stitches against 480, a 3.7-inch display against 5.7 and stitches up to 7 mm wide instead of 9.
Choose PFAFF creative 4.5 if…
you embroider large designs, up to 360 × 200 mm with the Deluxe hoop of the large unit, and want a wider repertoire: 480 built-in stitches and 270 designs, stitches up to 9 mm wide and 6 mm long, a 5.7-inch display. The trade-off: 3 embroidery fonts instead of 13, USB only and 11.5 kg of weight.
Where to buy
Paid link: the price for you does not change.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The purchase links are the same as on the two product pages and don't influence the verdict. The product pages have the complete data.