Janome HD718 vs PFAFF select 4.2
Technical comparison · Mechanical
Two mid-range mechanical machines with different ideas: the Janome keeps a short repertoire (18 stitches), while the PFAFF has 40 and a built-in dual feed, a second feed above the fabric that moves it forward together with the feed dogs.
| Parameter | ||
|---|---|---|
| Awards | — | |
| Identity | ||
| Use tier | F2 — Intermediate | F2 — Intermediate |
| Price | ||
| Price | — | ~450–1000 € |
| Universal specs | ||
| Weight | 8.5 kg | 11 kg |
| Category specs | ||
| Stitch selection | Dials | Buttons |
| Maximum speed | — | 900 spm |
| Built-in stitches | 18 | 40 |
| Buttonhole type | — | Four-step |
| Stitch types | Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Triple stretch straight stitch, Three-step zigzag, Blind hem stitch | Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Blind hem stitch, Stretch blind hem stitch, Elastic overlock stitch |
| Maximum stitch width | 6.5 mm | 5.5 mm |
| Maximum stitch length | 4 mm | 6 mm |
| Space to the right of the needle | — | 173 mm |
| Hook type | Horizontal rotary | — |
| Feed dog pieces | 5 | — |
| Drop feed | Yes | Yes |
| Dual feed / walking foot system | — | Integrated in the machine |
| Needle threader | Built-in | Semi-automatic |
| Automatic thread cutter | — | No |
| Adjustable presser foot pressure | Yes | — |
| Free arm | Yes | — |
| Thread tension | Manual | Manual |
| Independent bobbin winder | No | Yes |
| Included presser feet | 7 | 8 |
| Presser foot attachment | Low shank, snap-on | — |
SewingSpecs Awards
Most capable Intermediate
Highest technical score among the 6 sheets in the Mechanical category (intermediate tier): 100/100.
How we assign awards →No awards in this tier.
The differences that matter
- Built-in dual feed only on the PFAFF → both layers advance at the same pace, so a multi-layer seam does not creep out of line.
- 18 stitches against 40 → the PFAFF adds stretch blind hem and stretch overlock, which the Janome lacks.
- 8.5 kg against 11 kg → the Janome is easier to move from one table to another.
- Zigzag at 6.5 mm against 5.5 mm → the Janome opens the stitch a full millimetre wider.
Which one to choose
Choose Janome HD718 if…
Hems, repairs and wide zigzags up to 6.5 mm on an 8.5 kg machine, with a built-in needle threader and seven presser feet included. The trade-off: no dual feed, 18 stitches, and the bobbin winder is not independent.
Choose PFAFF select 4.2 if…
Seams through several layers or on fabrics that tend to shift, where the dual feed keeps both edges aligned, plus four-step buttonholes and an independent bobbin winder. You accept an 11 kg machine, a zigzag that stops at 5.5 mm and a semi-automatic needle threader.
Where to buy
Paid link: the price for you does not change.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The purchase links are the same as on the two product pages and don't influence the verdict. The product pages have the complete data.