Janome HD718 vs PFAFF select 4.2

Technical comparison · Mechanical

In brief

Two mid-range mechanical machines with different ideas: the Janome keeps a short repertoire (18 stitches), while the PFAFF has 40 and a built-in dual feed, a second feed above the fabric that moves it forward together with the feed dogs.

Parameter
Awards —
Identity
Use tier F2 — Intermediate F2 — Intermediate
Price
Price — ~450–1000 €
Universal specs
Weight 8.5 kg 11 kg
Category specs
Stitch selection Dials Buttons
Maximum speed — 900 spm
Built-in stitches 18 40
Buttonhole type — Four-step
Stitch types Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Triple stretch straight stitch, Three-step zigzag, Blind hem stitch Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Blind hem stitch, Stretch blind hem stitch, Elastic overlock stitch
Maximum stitch width 6.5 mm 5.5 mm
Maximum stitch length 4 mm 6 mm
Space to the right of the needle — 173 mm
Hook type Horizontal rotary —
Feed dog pieces 5 —
Drop feed Yes Yes
Dual feed / walking foot system — Integrated in the machine
Needle threader Built-in Semi-automatic
Automatic thread cutter — No
Adjustable presser foot pressure Yes —
Free arm Yes —
Thread tension Manual Manual
Independent bobbin winder No Yes
Included presser feet 7 8
Presser foot attachment Low shank, snap-on —

SewingSpecs Awards

Janome HD718

Most capable Intermediate

Highest technical score among the 6 sheets in the Mechanical category (intermediate tier): 100/100.

How we assign awards →
PFAFF select 4.2

No awards in this tier.

The differences that matter

  • Built-in dual feed only on the PFAFF → both layers advance at the same pace, so a multi-layer seam does not creep out of line.
  • 18 stitches against 40 → the PFAFF adds stretch blind hem and stretch overlock, which the Janome lacks.
  • 8.5 kg against 11 kg → the Janome is easier to move from one table to another.
  • Zigzag at 6.5 mm against 5.5 mm → the Janome opens the stitch a full millimetre wider.

Which one to choose

Choose Janome HD718 if…

Hems, repairs and wide zigzags up to 6.5 mm on an 8.5 kg machine, with a built-in needle threader and seven presser feet included. The trade-off: no dual feed, 18 stitches, and the bobbin winder is not independent.

See the Janome HD718 sheet →

Choose PFAFF select 4.2 if…

Seams through several layers or on fabrics that tend to shift, where the dual feed keeps both edges aligned, plus four-step buttonholes and an independent bobbin winder. You accept an 11 kg machine, a zigzag that stops at 5.5 mm and a semi-automatic needle threader.

See the PFAFF select 4.2 sheet →

Where to buy

Paid link: the price for you does not change.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The purchase links are the same as on the two product pages and don't influence the verdict. The product pages have the complete data.