Brother XM2701 vs PFAFF select 4.2

Technical comparison · Mechanical

In brief

The Brother XM2701 and the PFAFF select 4.2 are both mechanical machines, but not the same size of machine: the XM2701 is an entry model, the select 4.2 sits a step above and says so in the figures — 40 stitches against 27, 900 stitches per minute against 800, eight presser feet included. Two things stay easier on the Brother: the buttonhole and the threading. This comparison is for someone starting out who needs to work out whether that extra step changes the work.

Parameter
Identity
Use tier F1 — Entry F2 — Intermediate
Price
Price ~90–200 € ~450–1000 €
Universal specs
Weight — 11 kg
Category specs
Power supply 110-120 V —
Stitch selection Dials Buttons
Maximum speed 800 spm 900 spm
Built-in stitches 27 40
Buttonhole type One-step Four-step
Buttonhole styles 1 —
Stitch types Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Blind hem stitch, Three-step zigzag, Stretch blind hem stitch, Triple stretch straight stitch, Triple stretch zigzag, Elastic overlock stitch Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Blind hem stitch, Stretch blind hem stitch, Elastic overlock stitch
Maximum stitch width 5 mm 5.5 mm
Maximum stitch length 4 mm 6 mm
Space to the right of the needle — 173 mm
Feed dog pieces 6 —
Drop feed — Yes
Dual feed / walking foot system — Integrated in the machine
Needle threader Automatic Semi-automatic
Automatic thread cutter No No
Knee lifter No —
Adjustable presser foot pressure No —
Free arm Yes —
Thread tension Manual Manual
Display None —
Start/stop button No —
Independent bobbin winder No Yes
Included presser feet — 8

The differences that matter

  • Built-in stitches: 27 on the XM2701, 40 on the select 4.2. Declared stitch types run the other way, eight against five: Brother also lists the three-step zigzag and the triple stretch stitches.
  • Stitch width and length: 5 and 4 mm against 5.5 and 6 mm. The extra 2 mm of length is what basting and topstitching use.
  • Buttonhole: one step on the XM2701, four steps on the select 4.2 — the one thing the entry machine does in fewer moves.
  • Dual feed and droppable feed dogs: declared only by the select 4.2; Brother publishes neither figure for the XM2701.
  • Bobbin winder: independent on the select 4.2, not independent on the XM2701.
  • Speed: 800 stitches per minute against 900.

Which one to choose

Choose Brother XM2701 if…

you are starting out and sew garments and repairs: the buttonhole is done in a single pass, the needle threader is automatic, and eight stitch types are declared against five — among them the three-step zigzag and the triple stretch straight stitch for seams that have to give. The feed dog, the toothed bar that moves the fabric under the foot, has six points.

See the Brother XM2701 sheet →

Choose PFAFF select 4.2 if…

the work is growing: 40 stitches against 27, 5.5 mm of width against 5 and 6 mm of length against 4, with integrated dual feed — the fabric is pulled from above as well as by the feed dogs under the foot — and feed dogs that drop for free-motion quilting. The bobbin winder is independent: it winds a bobbin without moving the needle, which the XM2701 cannot do.

See the PFAFF select 4.2 sheet →

Where to buy

Paid link: the price for you does not change.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The purchase links are the same as on the two product pages and don't influence the verdict. The product pages have the complete data.