Brother JX2517 vs PFAFF select 4.2

Technical comparison · Mechanical

In brief

PFAFF select 4.2 is ahead on maximum stitch width; beyond that the two differ in stitch selection and stitch types, which is a design choice rather than a ranking. On the category's technical index, PFAFF select 4.2 ranks #6 of 14, Brother JX2517 #7.

Parameter
Brother JX2517 JX2517 Brother F1 · Entry
PFAFF select 4.2 select 4.2 Pfaff F2 · Intermediate
Identity
Use tier F1 — Entry F2 — Intermediate
Price
Price — ~450–1000 €
Universal specs
Weight — 11 kg
Category specs
Power supply 110-120 V —
Stitch selection Dials Buttons
Maximum speed 900 spm 900 spm
Built-in stitches 38 40
Buttonhole type Four-step Four-step
Buttonhole styles 1 —
Stitch types Zigzag stitch, Straight stitch, Blind hem stitch, Three-step zigzag, Stretch blind hem stitch Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Blind hem stitch, Stretch blind hem stitch, Elastic overlock stitch
Maximum stitch width 5 mm 5.5 mm
Maximum stitch length 4 mm 6 mm
Space to the right of the needle — 173 mm
Feed dog pieces 4 —
Drop feed — Yes
Dual feed / walking foot system — Integrated in the machine
Needle threader Manual Semi-automatic
Automatic thread cutter No No
Knee lifter No —
Adjustable presser foot pressure No —
Free arm Yes —
Thread tension Manual Manual
Display None —
Start/stop button No —
Independent bobbin winder No Yes
Included presser feet — 8

The differences that matter

  • Maximum stitch width: Brother JX2517 5 mm vs PFAFF select 4.2 5.5 mm — PFAFF select 4.2 wins (+10%)
  • Stitch selection: Brother JX2517 Dials · PFAFF select 4.2 Buttons
  • Stitch types: Brother JX2517 Zigzag stitch, Straight stitch, Blind hem stitch, Three-step zigzag, Stretch blind hem stitch · PFAFF select 4.2 Straight stitch, Zigzag stitch, Blind hem stitch, Stretch blind hem stitch, Elastic overlock stitch
  • Needle threader: Brother JX2517 Manual · PFAFF select 4.2 Semi-automatic

Which one to choose

Choose Brother JX2517 if…

you prefer this set-up — stitch selection: dials; needle threader: manual.

See the Brother JX2517 sheet →

Choose PFAFF select 4.2 if…

you value maximum stitch width.

See the PFAFF select 4.2 sheet →

This comparison points to the two product pages, where you'll find the complete data and the official links.